how to reduce laboratory errors

Find out more about our upcoming webinars and access previous recordings. Rin (2009) observes that a comprehensive five-step interrelated plan has been devised to reduce errors in Australian laboratories. The report concludes that strategies to reduce errors involving laboratory testing must entail all phases of the laboratory testing process and engage all stakeholders in that process. It would not be out of place to recommend hiring of a dedicated team for the task. The most common causes were clotted samples and insufficient volume for testing. In 1999, Berwick and Leape published that the estimated cost of medical errors in the United States was between $17 billion-$29 billion . Systematic errors are flaws in an experiments design or procedures that shift all measurements in the same direction. 2022 Dec 19;33:e00303. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0268764. 2022 Jun 3;17(6):e0268764. Estimation errors: On some instruments, reading a measurement is subject to errors in human estimation. Discover a unified scientific system with unparalleled breadth and depth of capabilities. An official website of the United States government. We designed our first scorecard to capture the reasons that tests are canceled and their distribution across hospital wards (i.e., pediatric units, general medicine units, intensive care units, etc.). Layfield J. L, Anderson M. G. Specimen labelling errors in surgical pathology:An 18-month experience. When tests are regularly incorrect, laboratory quality is impacted. The paper sought to examine the methods that different countries are applying to reduce errors in medical laboratories. Detection, identification, and monitoring of the error and implementing strategies to improve preanalytical quality reduces error numbers and thereby improves patient safety and health system outcomes. Using Performance Scorecards to Reduce Errors | AACC.org The certification given depends on the kind and complexity of testing taking place in the laboratory (Walz, 2013). Is this the end of fit to fly COVID-19 PCR tests? eCollection 2023 Jan. PLoS One. Proficiency testing programs and external assessment schemes have been found to be effective in reducing laboratory errors. Julianne Gallo, MT (ASCP), is the technical coordinator of laboratory education and audits and the pathology safety coach at University Hospitals of Cleveland. Performance scorecards show promise as a method of examining our complex processes in a systematic fashion, both to identify areas for improvement and to provide actionable data to improve the quality of patient care. This prompted us to develop a separate scorecard, reviewed monthly by the phlebotomy manager, to track the total number of draws performed by each phlebotomist compared to the number of specimens that were clotted or of insufficient quantity. Laboratory error is defined as any defect from ordering tests to reporting and interpretation of results. The site is secure. Scorecards also help the lab clearly measure progress toward a goal, often using simple visualizations such as arrows, numbers, or color-coding. Figure 2 in the appendix presents the rates and types of errors that occur in the three laboratory testing phases. (2010) highlight the importance of implementing effective modern technology and supporting decision-making processes in reducing cases of clinical laboratory errors. Data entry operators should be allowed short breaks after every couple of hours or so. How to use post-analytical data to improve performance, efficiency and reduce errors-Critical range alerts at the time of authentication Getting the wrong medicine or the wrong dose of medicine. A study conducted by Layfield and Anderson (2010) revealed that 75% of the errors, in a study of a span of 18 months, involved wrong patient labelling. This is essential to maintain, Your email address will not be published. National Library of Medicine The role of the external quality assessment. Its estimated that errors cost an average U.S. lab about $180,000 each year in the pre- and post-analytical stages. Many miscalculations and accidents in labs result from human error. Figuring out assignments early and putting the appropriate lines of communication in place will make closing the loop after each scorecard review a seamless process. A Lab Information System (LIS), which offers data on clinical correlation and reflux testing has now become a necessity. Addressing such problems can help to attract more candidates into the profession and hence, face out the problem of shortage. Some laboratories have installed automated analyzers in an attempt to reduce errors or to generate credible laboratory results. For instance, the number of trained medical technologists in clinical laboratories in the UK has been reducing over the last one decade. A simple way to understand and practice the clauses covered by ISO 17025:2005, Differences between Verification, Calibration and Validation, Coordination & Strong Communication-Pillars of success of Laboratory Operations. According to Hammerling (2012), the difficulties in translating new knowledge to practice and implementing new technology are among the factors inhibiting effective reduction of errors in medical laboratories. No fresh sample may be needed and can save crucial time too. You can find out more about laboratory workflow automation here. We implemented a second, more specific iteration of this scorecard to help us identify which integrity issues were responsible for the most cancellations. We have used performance scorecards to evaluate the most frequent reasons behind test order cancellations and result corrections due to technical errors. Email: [emailprotected]. haemoglobin concentration, platelet count, prothrombin time and much more. Report approval in isolation can lead to incorrect clinical interpretation at times. Continuous laboratory staff changes create the need to establish improvement strategies to reduce the error risk. First, equipment should be regularly maintained and calibrated. Hammerling J. To prevent accidents and mistakes from occurring, make sure to provide ample training to all laboratory staff regarding proper processes, procedures, and equipment use. The fundamental causes of the problem are the lack of attractive remuneration and too much pressure, among others. Cureus. Review of Medical Errors in Laboratory Diagnostics and Where We Are Other clinical applications have also been employed to ensure that recording of patient data is easily done, even at the bedside. The educational program for nursing personnel is relevant and important as can be seen in the decrease of sample errors and the resulting quality improvement. It has been 12 years since the Institute of Medicine (IOM) reported the alarming data on the cause and impact of medical errors in the United States. It is important to take breaks. Sciacovelli L, et al. // Inconsistencies in the laboratory environment can also skew experiment or test results. In diagnostics labs, human error can lead to a number of avoidable issues, including: Eliminating manual processes is one of the most effective methods to improve quality laboratory diagnostics. The policy also requires laboratories to have enough personnel to prevent errors that may occur as a result of work overload due to staff shortage. The article has also established that laboratory directors and the pathologists are not satisfied with the training system for the laboratory staff. Problem The specimen receiving and processing department is the key entry point at the Riyadh Regional Laboratory (RRL) of the Ministry of Health. What You Can Do To Stay Safe. This is even more relevant for data entry operations as the nature of task can get monotonous over extended periods. doi: 10.1016/j.plabm.2022.e00303. The https:// ensures that you are connecting to the It will also provide a better experience for staff by helping them understand their role in the quality improvement initiative and own their contribution to the process. Setting challenging performance targets can be inspiring and leads to stronger performance, but be cautious of setting unrealistic goals because they will have the opposite effect. It is important for them to realize about untold damage that can result from entering wrong values. van Dongen-Lases EC, Cornes MP, Grankvist K, Ibarz M, Kristensen GB, Lippi G, Nybo M, Simundic AM; Working Group for Preanalytical Phase (WG-PRE), European Federation of Clinical Chemistry and Laboratory Medicine (EFLM). There are universal, as well as national regulations that regulate the qualifications for entry into the medical laboratory profession in different countries. A variety of resources available from ECRI Institute and elsewhere discuss specimen-related risks and best practices for preventing them. Different countries have different certification requirements for clinical laboratories. To help design realistic targets, use historical data for your institution or external sources of performance data from comparable institutions. Implementing extra checks, including those conducted by a disinterested party, can help experimenters avoid confirmation bias. There are a number of ways that automation can help prevent human error, and ensure patients receive timely and high quality results. Bethesda, MD 20894, Web Policies Many of the human errors in this category can be reduced or eliminated by delivering proper training to staff, as well as providing sufficient breaks or alternating tasks to maintain vigilance. Most academic studies need to be conducted in this crucial area in order to ascertain the role of adequate skills in reducing laboratory errors. These steps include developing written procedures that are clear, enhancing healthcare professional training, monitoring laboratory indicators, automating laboratory functions, and improving communication among the healthcare providers, and also between the care providers and the patients. However, the pre- and post-analytical stages have been found to be more prone to errors than the analysis phases. Inclusion in an NLM database does not imply endorsement of, or agreement with, Rin (2009) suggests that nurses should receive training in order to make this implementation process a success. A laboratory earns its recognition and repute over the years through accurate and timely delivery of analysis reports. Visualizing progress in this way motivates staff and makes the meaning of success more tangible. When tests are regularly incorrect, laboratory quality is impacted. The main cause of the problem is that some phases are not in direct control of the laboratory personnel. The pre-analytical stage includes the procedures that are carried out before the analysis of the samples of the patients. 1 Besides causing serious harm to patients, medical errors translate into huge costs for the national economy. Rin D. G. Pre-analytical workstations:A tool for reducing laboratory errors. document.getElementById( "ak_js_2" ).setAttribute( "value", ( new Date() ).getTime() ); Common Types of Analytical Errors in Laboratory and Ways to Solve Them by Dr. Gaur, Labs can now Scan Documents and Register Patients, CrelioHealth Inc., Wilmington Delaware, USA 19808, Lab matrix to be considered in Histopathology testing, New trends in histopathology data analysis & management. The automated analyzers are capable of producing multiple results in a short time. To avoid adding meaningless metrics to your scorecard, start by defining the strategic goals and objectives of your institution, then select metrics that are aligned and ultimately serve to gauge progress toward the goal. What is a LIMS (Laboratory Information Management System)? Bookshelf Finally,Test Tracking and Follow-Upprovides risk management strategies to help healthcare organizations improve practices and processes related to test tracking and follow-up. Plebani M. Exploring the iceberg of errors in laboratory medicine. According to Lippi, Plebani and imundi (2010), efforts tailored to reduce medical laboratory errors have been successful in improving patient care in many cases. 2009;404(1):16-23. Please enable scripts and reload this page. We developed a scorecard that tracked the total number of technical errors requiring a correction to the initial result reported, the distribution of each type of error (e.g., dilutions, manual entry error), the lab tech responsible for each error and the corrective action taken if necessary. The problems have contributed immensely to the numerous cases of errors that occur in clinical laboratories (Zima, 2010). A total of 17 research articles have been reviewed. Although errors can occur throughout the laboratory testing process, the majority occur in the preanalytic phase of testing, which involves test selection and ordering, specimen collection and handling, and specimen transport. Regulatory agencies use guidance and enforcement tools, while companies have policies, processes, and procedures. In some cases, they emanate from the wide range of mechanical, chemical, biological and environmental hazards that the laboratory practices involve (Buesa, 2007). Dintzis M. S, Stetsenko Y. G, Sitlani M. C, Grownoski M. A, Astion M. L, Galagher H. T. Communicating pathology and laboratory errors:Anatomic pathologists and laboratory medical directors attitudes and experiences. The current article examines the modern practices of reducing errors in medical laboratories. http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/, http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.cca.2009.03.024, http://dx.doi.org/10.1309/AJCPJF1YUFG6GTFI, http://dx.doi.org/10.1309/AJCPHLQHJ0S3DFJK, http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.cca.2009.03.020, http://dx.doi.org/10.3109/00365510903307962. They should be made to realize the significance of entering values correctly each and every time otherwise all their dedication can go in vain. The cost of poor blood specimen quality and errors in preanalytical processes. Theguidance articleDiagnostic Errors: Monumental Problem or Enormous Opportunity? and transmitted securely. Further, the laboratories are required to make arrangements that would ensure that clients do not lose confidence in the services they provide. Many laboratory processes, such as specimen labeling, specimen transport, and test results reporting, are good candidates for FMEA. Epub 2017 Feb 27. The benefits of speed can still be realized if additional data entry staff is hired for equitable distribution of workload. Errors often happen in lab testing, because humans arent designed to conduct laborious and repetitive tasks, such as pipetting. The errors lead to a significant harm and inconveniences in patient care. Green SF. Three years of preanalytical errors: quality specifications and improvement through implementation of statistical process control. PMID: 23163106 Abstract Background: A correct preanalytical phase procedure is critical to get an adequate sample and consequently to achieve the most reliable laboratory results, promoting patient safety. We will be learning about this in our future blogs. Da Rin (2009), also emphasizes that the increase in the reduction of laboratory errors has a connection to the lack of adequate training of medical laboratory personnel. Calibration errors can also occur if equipment is not serviced periodically and maintained to a high standard. 8600 Rockville Pike Medical errors: impact on clinical laboratories and other critical areas. AACC.org To some extent, errors are an inevitable part of the drug discovery and development process. Laboratory errors and patient safety - PubMed Relying on robotic equipment to perform various lab tasks, such as the sorting, loading, and centrifugation of specimens, can greatly reduce errors in measurement or breaches of experimental protocols. Its not productive to report something just for the sake of reporting ita real temptation as technology offers more and more data. A well-designed scorecard will make it easier to see how a process is performing overall and facilitate drilling down into the layers of data when outliers are identified. Quality improvement project: Reducing non-conformities of the samples for haemostasis testing in a secondary healthcare centre through the nurses' education in phlebotomy. Second, staff should be properly trained and supervised in operating instruments and recording data to minimize deviation from experimental protocols. The eventual impact of such errors is the poor quality of care that is provided to patients. In terms of personnel, the UK laboratories are headed by a laboratory director, just like in the US. Date: APR.1.2018 Lab technicians, scientists and clinicians also have to receive significant training and education to ensure they are qualified to carry out their complex roles. Data entry operators should be allowed short breaks after every couple of hours or so. The post-analytic phase is the final phase of the laboratory testing process. Continuous monitoring and educational initiatives have highly contributed to the reduction of the errors in the laboratories. Speed of data entry helps achieve set targets but at same time there should be no compromise on accuracy. The paper has done a comparison of pathology laboratory practices in the US, Canada, the UK and Australia, regarding laboratory staff skills and error reduction. The systems are also accompanied by test tube kits that contain the spaces that the laboratory staff should just fill. In Australia, several strategies have been adopted to reduce laboratory errors. The errors have significant implications because they affect the reproducibility, precision, accuracy and repeatability of results. In diagnostic labs, it's crucial that tests are accurate and precise. The PubMed wordmark and PubMed logo are registered trademarks of the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services (HHS). Before Its very important to do the assessment of the significance of results in the context of established reference values and decisions for further tests. For example, instead of entering 536 through oversight 563 is entered. With an ELN, predefining options for data entry cuts down on transcriptional errors. Your email address will not be published. Experimenter fatigue or inexperience: Lack of experience with equipment can cause measurements to be inaccurate or unreliable. Another improvement is the introduction of barcode ID wristbands for both the outpatients and inpatients. Email: [emailprotected]. Staff must label the specimen containers at the time of collection in the presence of the patient and use two acceptable patient identifiers. The automatic workstations have helped to reduce errors of labelling, sorting, routing and pour-off. The lack of improvement over time suggested that there were issues at play other than unfamiliarity with the new equipment and computer systems (See Table). Lippi G, Plebani M, imundi A. M. Quality in laboratory diagnostics:From theory to practice. When humans make mistakes, expensive compounds and components can be wasted, and thats before the time to clean up, fix and re-perform the process is considered. Apart from these, inventory assessment, quality reviews, artificial intelligence and machine learning etc can be extremely helpful in identifying diseases, planning the next steps of diagnosis, & course of action and new testing. Lippi G, Plebani M. The importance of incident reporting in laboratory diagnostics. Blood venous sample collection: Recommendations overview and a checklist to improve quality. Pittsburgh Healthcare Report, an online consumer health publication, is a journalistic enterprise launched in the fall of 2011 with support from our parent publication, Western Pennsylvania Healthcare News. Epub 2009 Oct 25. Scientific R&D Data Liquidity: What It Is and Why It Matters, Latest insights and perspectives to lead your R&D, Success stories featuring Dotmatics customers. However, poor labeling can cause samples to get misplaced, thrown out, or utilized incorrectly. A laboratory workflow automation solution in diagnostic testing may process, test and store specimens autonomously, with minimal human intervention. Corrective measures for these activities were established: educational program for nurses and a system of custom labels, which correlate each laboratory test in the Laboratory Information System (LIS) with the corresponding tube. Whether you work in a medical or a research lab, there is not a lot of room for error. Specific risk areas identified in the query included: In 2013, ECRI Institute Patient Safety Organization (PSO) conducted an analysis of laboratory events submitted to the PSO's database and found that the top two types of laboratory errors involved specimens (mislabeled specimens and specimens with incomplete or missing labels). This is where your laboratory software (LIMS) can be extremely useful wherein all abnormal values are highlighted and linked to give a better clinical direction. When conducting an experiment or test, its essential to know exactly what each sample is, as using a sample that has uncertain contents can pose a significant risk for error. All employees must be indoctrinated on importance of authentic data right from the day they start working in laboratories. According to Da Rin (2009), accountability should also be improved using performance and outcome measures. In the UK, the Clinical Pathology Accreditation (CPA-UK) recognizes that a laboratory is an entity that should be held legally responsible (CPA-UK, 2007). We should always ask ourselves if tracking any particular metric will inform our decisions. A Review Article of the Reduce Errors in Medical Laboratories

Cause Conference 2022, Articles H